4
$\begingroup$

I have a 30ish year old travel mug from Sheetz that I intend to model and print using my OpenScad skills. The fact that it is an insulated mug means that the inside is hollow to an extent.

What reccomendations do you have toward turning this into a foodsafe, leakproof success?

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Hi! Do you intend to use this mug for hot liquids or cold only? Many thermoplastics will start to soften between 50-100C, which might limit your options considerably. $\endgroup$ – Tormod Haugene May 8 '16 at 19:21
  • $\begingroup$ Both, though it is intended to be a coffee mug primarily $\endgroup$ – EvilTeach May 8 '16 at 19:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Why do you want to 3D print a travel mug? It will be almost impossible to get satisfactory results, a store-bought one will be both vastly higher quality and vastly cheaper. Insulated mugs also tend to have a vacuum on the inside, which is something you definitely can't print. $\endgroup$ – Tom van der Zanden May 9 '16 at 7:13
  • $\begingroup$ You should mention what printing technology you're using. On this site, it's common practice to presume it's FDM but for the sake of clarity (and for future reference, when other printing processes might be more common) you should mention explicitly what printing technology the question is about. $\endgroup$ – Tom van der Zanden May 9 '16 at 20:02
  • $\begingroup$ I noticed that your question has not had much activity lately, are you still looking for an answer to this question? How might we be able to close some gaps? $\endgroup$ – tbm0115 Jul 3 '16 at 20:26
9
$\begingroup$

You cannot make a safe coffee cup using home FDM printers. There are no printable thermoplastics available to consumers/hobbyists that will reliably AND safely contain coffee/tea temperature beverages.

Even though some plastics may appear mechanically suitable at first sight, there are long-term issues with using thermoplastics for elevated temperature service. The material becomes weaker and less dimensionally stable under load as the temperature approaches the glass point of the polymer. For example, here is some Stratasys test data for ABS strength versus temperature:

enter image description here

Even if the plastic survives a few uses, it may creep and warp over time. And that might be fine, depending on your needs! People have printed working coffee cups out of ABS before. For some definition of "working" you can make print a working coffee mug. It's just not going to work at the level of longevity and reliability that people typically expect from hot beverage containers. (Imagine if the handle breaks and pours scalding liquid in your lap.) PLA in particular tends to give out abruptly due to its unusual ability to creep to ultimate failure with very low elongations.

Then there is the question of whether ANY FDM printed part is ever safe for repeated food service use. One-time uses (such as throw-away cookie cutters) might be perfectly fine, but repeated use introduces additional problems because FDM parts are porous. They contain a microscopic void/grain structure that is perfect for trapping food debris and sheltering bacteria. Every FDM part is similar in that regard to an old, scratched, wooden cutting board. They are difficult to effectively sanitize. A high-temp dishwasher cycle will do the job, but that imposes significant thermal stress on thermoplastics.

Here's an example micrograph I took of voids in a printed part (strands all aligned the same way to highlight the shape):

enter image description here

These voids will also allow liquids to leak unless careful print settings are used. Over-extruding with multiple perimeters, or doing some kind of post-print sealing can make water-tight parts. It's not hard, just takes some experimenting.

There is also considerable anecdotal evidence that much of the cheap filament from Asia is full of nasty, toxic substances that may leach into hot beverages. Heavy metals like lead, strontrium, and cadmium are often found in thermoplastics as processing aids, pigments, or simply from unscrupulous companies disposing of industrial ashes by mixing them into dark-colored filaments for export. US-made and EU-made filaments seem to be better in this regard.

Now that the basic issues are out of the way... Here is the breakdown of specific materials you might want to try:

  • PLA blends used in 3d printing will soften and fail almost instantly on contact with hot beverages. (They contain melt-reducers and viscosity modifiers and polymer molecular weights specific to FDM filament and will perform differently from injection-molded PLA products.) It is possible to anneal PLA to survive higher temperatures, as this increases the crystallinity of the polymer and thus makes it more heat-stable. However, that is highly experimental and results will vary considerably with filament provider, color/pigment, and annealing process used. Even annealed PLA is unlikely to survive long-term against very hot beverages and dishwasher use.
  • ABS will become fairly weak at hot beverage temperatures. It may survive use for a while, but is quite weak and will slowly creep with very hot beverages or in a high-temp dishwasher. ABS IS approved for food use in many contexts, despite what many people think, but hot beverages are not one of the approved uses.
  • PET blends are chemically a pretty good choice -- soda bottles are PET -- but generally have glass points around 70-75C and thus will be weak or fail outright at hot beverage temperatures. It is also important to ask what is being blended into the PET. For example, PETG is "glycol modified" but filament vendors do not share any details about this or reveal how it may affect the polymer's leaching behavior.
  • Most nylons will creep under load at surprisingly low temperatures, perhaps 50-55C depending on the blend. Nylons are also attacked by acids and will absorb stains and smells from coffee. Nylons also tend to swell/shrink quite dramatically on exposure to water, so mechanical fit and general shape of nylon parts may not be stable enough even for cold beverage service. Taulman's 910 is probably a good candidate for hot beverage service due to its high working temperature, but acid attack from coffee exposure may still be an issue in the long run. It's worth trying.
  • Polycarbonate is thermally stable even in boiling water, so mechanically it is fine, but PC leaches BPA (one of the monomers left over from manufacture) into hot liquids.
  • High-temp exotics like Ultem and PEEK aren't printable by consumer/hobbyist printers at the size scale required for a coffee mug. They simply warp too much unless you have an oven for a heated build chamber.

In summary, you can make a working coffee mug via FDM printing, but it isn't a great idea. Your best bet for 3d printing a coffee mug is ordering ceramic printed from an online service bureau.

| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Did you get the graph from Stratasys' website? I've been trying to find information like this for a while now. $\endgroup$ – tbm0115 Nov 29 '16 at 16:12
  • $\begingroup$ @tbm0115 Yeah, it was in a white paper they posted on their site a while back. $\endgroup$ – Ryan Carlyle Dec 13 '16 at 17:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.