4
$\begingroup$

I run a 3D printer farm and I have to replace my Bowden tubes on the printers after about a month or two of use(roughly 1000 hours of use). The Bowden tubes continually melt on the side of the tube very near to where it pushes against the nozzle. I am running Ender 3 Pros and I run at about 205 °C with PLA. The Bowden tubes I have are some I found on Amazon and they are not Capricorn tubes.

Note how the hole is very near the base of the tube closest to the nozzle

EDIT1: I have added more pictures below of a new failure. This time you can see the marks of the teeth of the coupler a good inch below the failure point. New photo of tube 1 New photo of tube 2 New photo of tube 3 New potho of tube 4

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Melting is virtually impossible, that happens at 327 °C. To me this looks more like wear. $\endgroup$ – 0scar Feb 19 at 18:44
  • $\begingroup$ Hmm, so you're saying that wear caused a tear in the tube? $\endgroup$ – Daniel Bozarth Feb 19 at 18:48
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I'm saying that it cannot be melting caused by heat of printing PLA :) It looks as if it is wear. What other failure modes are possible? $\endgroup$ – 0scar Feb 19 at 18:51
2
$\begingroup$

If the tube is PTFE, the tube is not likely to be melting unless your hotend temperature is out of control. You would probably notice the PLA cooking.

So, perhaps they aren't PTFE, or perhaps it is wear.

If it wasn't PTFE, you should be able to tell by the texture, slipperiness, and bending force.

The four thinned faces look like they would correspond to four of the barbs in the connector. The thinned ring below the four thinned faces look like a wear line where the tube is pressing against the exit of the connector. It looks to me as if the tube is moving or flexing in the connector. The barbs act as little chisels cutting into the tube, which is how they restrain such a slippery material as PTFE.

It might work better if the tube were a little longer. This might reduce the forces at the limits of movement which may be placing strain on the tubes. If you can, you might also fashion a strain relief for the tube so that it doesn't bend right as it exist from the connector. If you can cut down on the movement, you will help with the external wear.

It is also possible that the tubes are being strained by a high filament pressure. All the drive to push filament into the hot end is matched by an equivalent reverse pressure from the tube onto the connector. If you can stand a higher print temperature, the life of the tube may be increased.

@towe added a comment:

I don't think those are marks from the teeth of the pneumatic coupler. The questions states "where it pushes against the nozzle", and the Ender 3 Pro seems to have a hot-end where the Bowden tube reaches all the way through the cold end and heat break to the nozzle.

A mechanical drawing of what may be a MK-10 hot-end as used on the Ender 3 Pro also suggests that the Ender 3 Pro has a PTFE lined hot end. Lets accept that drawing as confirming that @towe is right. Never-the-less, the marks you show in the photo look like the types of cuts I have seen from a pneumatic coupler. How can we reconcile this contradiction?

The most direct answer would be that the tube is not reaching through to the nozzle. In the photo you don't show enough of the blue tube to show the coupler scars which should be a little further up the tube. Suppose that, in fact, the tube is not pressing against the nozzle. This might not be the case if any of these are true:

  1. There is a separate piece of PTFE that is permanently in hot end. The Creality Ender 3 Pro looks as if it is not configured for a Bowden feed. A PTFE lined hot-end for a direct extruder would have a piece of PTFE cut to length in the hot-end. A simple mod to make that a Bowden would leave that sculpted PTFE tube in place.
  2. The pneumatic couplers have been replaced. Many couplers do not permit the tube to pass through them, although the hole in the end can be drilled to 4mm diameter. In fact, preventing the tube from passing through a pneumatic coupler is a feature in the intended application of coupling to air tubes in moderate pressure applications.
  3. There is a bump in the path that is catching the tube and preventing it from extending through to the cold end and onward.
| improve this answer | |
$\endgroup$
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I don't think those are marks from the teeth of the pneumatic coupler. The questions states "where it pushes against the nozzle", and the Ender 3 Pro seems to have a hotend where the bowden tube reaches all the way through the cold end and heat break to the nozzle. $\endgroup$ – towe Feb 20 at 12:17
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @towe, Thank you for your comment. With your encouragement, I looked deeper and added more information to my answer. $\endgroup$ – cmm Feb 20 at 14:52
  • $\begingroup$ I am afraid those marks are not from the pneumatic coupler, the gouges from the coupler are hidden just out of view by my thumb. I would take another picture and show you however I threw the piece away already. I know that the tube reaches all the way to the nozzle as there was no filament attached to the end of the tube which would happen as the filament approaches the nozzle and clogs any space between the nozzle and the tube end. $\endgroup$ – Daniel Bozarth Feb 21 at 23:56
  • $\begingroup$ The Ender 3 Pro is designed with Bowden tube feeding in mind, it is a stock feature and there is one only one continuous tube from the extruder driver to the butt of the nozzle. The pneumatic couplers have been replaced but they are the type to allow tubing to pass through them. $\endgroup$ – Daniel Bozarth Feb 22 at 1:31
  • $\begingroup$ @Daniel a remaining possibility, unbolt though it seems to me, is that the tubes are melting. If so they aren't suitable for the job. When you have another failure, please take lots of close up pictures. You could also try a melt test on the tube. Put it in a 300°C oven for a couple of hours and check for any change or softening. Maybe put a clip on it and see if the tube collapses. $\endgroup$ – cmm Feb 22 at 3:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.